Research finds older people less anxious, more active and less likely to fall in retirement communities

A new report shows older people benefit from improved physical and mental health in retirement communities, resulting in cost savings to the NHS.

Findings from the independent study into healthy ageing carried out by Aston and Lancaster Universities showed that residents living within a charity’s retirement communities:

• are more physically active (75% increase in exercise)
• benefit from a reduced risk of falls (18%)
• are less anxious (23%)
• have an increased walking speed
• were ‘never or hardly ever’ lonely (86.5%)
• have improved autobiographical (24%) and memory (17%) recall
• can delay or reverse the onset of frailt

The study was commissioned by the ExtraCare Charitable Trust, a registered charity that exists to create better lives for older people and operates 19 midlands and southern-based retirement villages and housing schemes. It follows the charity’s 2012-2015 research with Aston University which revealed a 14.8% reductions in depressive symptoms amongst residents after three years, and annual NHS savings of 38% per person.

The latest study by Lancaster University and led by Professor Carol Holland includes additional measures for loneliness, resilience and quality of life, and shows that the charity’s unique well-being and lifestyle model delivers significant health improvements, including residents reducing their average hospital stays by three days per year.

Shirley Hall, Head of Innovation and Well-being at The ExtraCare Charitable Trust comments: “We’re excited by the results of our study, we know older people who exercise tend to be happier and are likely to live longer healthier lives, so it’s great to see that residents within our communities are more physically active.

“However, the results do show a small number of residents are feeling lonely, so we need to help identify and support those who are. We know from the study that working on autobiographical memory is one area that our residents can work on to help improve ‘social connectedness’ and loneliness further, and supporting residents with mobility issues to build resilient social networks will be critical in reducing their level of loneliness over time, all things that the charity is committed to doing.”

“More importantly, our research shows that some critical factors where we’d expect to see a downward trend as a result of age, for example age-related changes in cognitive function that no such trends are emerging. This is having a knock on benefit for the NHS too, with ExtraCare residents visiting their GP less often, and staying in hospital for shorter periods. This takes pressure off the health system. This is in contrast to the usual expected increase in NHS costs as people age.”

The Baroness Sally Greengross OBE recently visited ExtraCare’s newly opened Hughenden Gardens Village in High Wycombe, she comments: “It’s terribly important that the example ExtraCare has set is more widely known and communicated to society, particularly people in local governments so that they can realise the benefits to the health service that these villages bring. These communities also help the increasingly difficult issue of social care, because care is on offer to those residents, if and when they need it, but with an emphasis on when you’re fit and well, being able to be independent again.”

Since the first study was published the charity has used the results to assess the efficacy of its award-winning well-being service, which supports all residents to be proactive in managing their own health and make informed decisions about their health and lifestyle, via regular assessments.

This latest research has helped inform the development of a resilience tool to measure how resilient residents are in terms of physical and cognitive health. The tool will launch this spring. It will be used to reassess residents who have already been identified as frail to determine if personal goals and targets are helping them to become more resilient. There are plans to roll the tool out to other retirement housing providers later in the year.

Over 4,500 residents, aged 55-100+ live in the charity’s retirement communities, most with 250 plus homes and up to 18 facilities including gyms, shops, hair salons, IT suites, hobby rooms and bistro restaurants. Residents live in one or two-bedroom apartments with care, well-being and dementia support available. For many their new homes have meant new friends and a new lease of life with access to a wide range of activities and volunteering opportunities including tai-chi, woodwork, chair yoga, choir singing and quiz nights.

Residents are developing focus on intergenerational living with a number of ‘play groups’ being set up within its communities following its successful participation in Channel Fours ‘Old People’s Home for Four Year Olds’ in 2018.

Nineteen villages and schemes were included within the research assessments with more than 160 residents involved. For the second report data from the participants was collected 24, 36, 48 and 60 months. Find out more information and read the full report here.

Research

The ExtraCare Charitable Trust has been working with Aston and Lancaster Universities looking into how its unique model of integrated housing, health and social care makes a real difference to older people’s lives. The research tested the impact of the charity’s approach on both quality of life and cost of health and social care for older people. The key results from both the 2012-15 and 2015-2018 research studies are as follows:

1. NHS costs reduce by 38%

2. Unplanned hospital stays reduced from 8-14 to 1-2 days

3. 46% reduction in routine and regular GP visits

4. 14.8% reduction in depressive symptoms in 18 months

5. 23% decrease in anxiety symptoms

6. Significant improvements in the level of exercise done by residents (75%)

7. Increase in walking speed and a reduction of falls over the first two years

8. The increase of frailty is delayed or reversed in residents

9. 24% increase in autobiographical and 17% increase in memory recall tests

10. 86.5% of residents were ‘never or hardly ever’ lonely

About The ExtraCare Charitable Trust

The ExtraCare Charitable Trust is a registered charity since 1988. Our vision is better lives for older people and our mission is creating sustainable communities that provide homes older people want, lifestyles they can enjoy and care if it’s needed. To deliver our vision and mission we essentially do three things:

• We develop new villages
• We operate villages and schemes
• We support our villages, schemes and our ‘extra-care’ model through fundraising, advocacy and research

Our villages and schemes each have 5 to 18 social, health and leisure facilities that are accessible to our residents, volunteers and local people representing all age groups living in surrounding communities. There are also three villages in development. Our Charity Shops help fund care and well-being services for older people living at our each of our locations.